NewsWest 9: Ruling for no high-level nuclear waste storage in the Permian Basin draws positive reactions

NewsWest 9 reported on local reaction to the Fifth Circuit's Aug. 25, 2023, decision that vacated the federal license for an interim storage site for spent nuclear fuel in Andrews County.
ANDREWS

NewsWest 9 · Published August 29, 2023 · Media coverage

Update, November 2026: This 2023 report describes a Fifth Circuit ruling that the U.S. Supreme Court reversed on June 18, 2025 (NRC v. Texas). The Interim Storage Partners license in Andrews County was reinstated. Texas law (HB 7, 2021, and HB 4112, 2025) bans storing high-level waste there. For the current status, see our Legal Timeline.

Summary

NewsWest 9 reported on local reaction to the Fifth Circuit’s Aug. 25, 2023, decision that vacated the federal license for an interim storage site for spent nuclear fuel in Andrews County.

People on the legal team for the Permian Basin Coalition of Land and Royalty Owners, Andrews County Judge Charlie Falcon and State Rep. Brooks Landgraf welcomed the ruling. Landgraf and Falcon pointed to House Bill 7, the 2021 state law banning high-level waste storage in Texas. The NRC told the station it was reviewing the decision.

Key excerpt

“The Permian Basin’s often a part of the United States that’s very overlooked.”

Brock McNeel, Permian Basin Coalition of Land and Royalty Owners, to NewsWest 9

Why it matters

This was the first court ruling to stop the Andrews County license. The story shows county officials, state lawmakers and landowners on the same side of the issue.

Where things stand now

Updated November 2026. On June 18, 2025, the Supreme Court ruled 6–3 in NRC v. Texas that Texas and the landowner petitioners could not challenge the ISP license in court. The Court did not decide whether the NRC had the authority to issue it. The Fifth Circuit dismissed the remaining petition on Oct. 20, 2025. Texas law bans storing high-level waste in the state (HB 7, 2021; HB 4112, 2025), but no court has ruled on whether that ban holds against a federal license.

Read the full article at NewsWest 9 →

See also: Legal Timeline · The Issue · Resource Library

DATE: OCT 12, 2024

Related